You are viewing an old blog post! That means that links will be broken, and images may be missing.

June 19, 2009

Complexity, Simplified

Media Notice: Today (Friday), Jim Babka is scheduled to appear on “Straight Talk w/ Jerry Hughes,” starting at 3:05 PM Eastern. Listening details can be found on the blog.

Quote of the Day: “You will be assimilated.” — The Borg (from Star Trek)

Subject: The complex health care issue made simple

If politicians can complicate an issue then they know our minds will freeze, our attention will wander, and we’ll let them do whatever they want. The health care issue is a classic example.

There are tax issues involved, state and federal regulations, and massive price distortions caused by programs like Medicare, Medicaid, and SCHIP. And the proposals for “reform” are tangled in jargon…

* Connectors
* Mandates
* Comparative effectiveness
* Guaranteed issue
* Pools
* Community rating

Hard-working taxpayers can’t possibly have the time and energy to understand it all. But we think the complexity can be simplified to two simple questions:

* For whom does your doctor work?
* Do you pay for your health insurance directly?

If your doctor tailors his or her care to the policies of your insurance company, or some government program, then you don’t really have a doctor who works for you, and health care hasn’t really been reformed.

You’ll know health care has really been reformed when the following things are true…

* You and your doctor deal with your health insurance provider as rarely as you currently do with your car insurance company
* Doctors post their prices, and compete with each other based on price and quality

It’s really that simple. As long as insurance policies and/or government programs fund most of your health care, doctors will work for them and not for you. 

The same holds true for health insurance. As long as our health care coverage comes mostly from employer controlled insurance or the government, we won’t have a competitive health insurance market, and the cost of both insurance and health care will grow constantly.

When Americans care about the impact that their use of health care has on their insurance premiums in the same way that they care about the impact that speeding tickets and minor scrapes have on their car insurance, you’ll know that our health care system has really been reformed.

We must reach the point where Americans are paying close attention to the cost and quality of both their insurance and their medical care, and are constantly looking for better deals and better service. You’ll know health care has really been reformed when…

* Few Americans have insurance through their employers
* People have portable major medical policies that they pay for directly
* There are no government mandates on what insurance must cover and consumers can buy the kind of coverage they want
* Government aid to indigent patients is provided by the states or charities, with NO federal involvement
* Medicare is optional and means-tested
* Any government funding of health care that remains comes through vouchers rather than direct payments to doctors and hospitals

When you see these things happen you’ll know that health care has really been reformed, because you’ll start seeing the positive results. People will…

* Watch what they eat, exercise, take their vitamins, and quit smoking, because their basic health care costs and health insurance premiums will be coming out of their own pockets
* Stay healthier longer, because they’ll be more focused on prevention
* Demand to see prices from doctors and hospitals so they can measure the impact on both their checking account and their insurance premiums
* Start shopping for the best deals, both in terms of price and quality

In addition…

* Doctors and hospitals will advertise their prices and the quality of their outcomes
* Insurance companies will compete on price and service just like car insurance companies do
* Consumers will rate doctors and hospitals on the Internet, the same way they rate books and products on Amazon
* The current surplus of specialists and the shortage of primary care physicians will correct itself, as real free market prices once again balance supply with demand
* The cost and quality of health care will constantly improve, just as it has with lasik eye surgery, which patients pay for directly

When you see these things happen you’ll know that health care has really been reformed. But…

Before we can achieve these results we must first stop the politicians from making things worse. We believe the real aim of the current proposals is to assimilate you into a system completely controlled by the government. Do not be assimilated!

Tell your Congressional employees to oppose all health care proposals that increase government involvement.

Use you personal comments to tell them they should only support proposals that restore consumer control. Cut and paste from this Downsizer-Dispatch if you want to add detail.

To exceed the 36,512 messages we sent last month we need to send at least 1,639 messages today.

Thank you for being a part of the growing Downsize DC Army.

Perry Willis
Communications Director, Inc.


We grew by 19 net new subscribers yesterday. This brings us to 1,412 net new army members for the year. The Downsize DC Army now stands at 25,761 — 76% of the way from 25,000 to 26,000!

YOU can make the army grow even faster by following our quick and easy instructions for personalized recruiting.

We can also grow faster by doing more outreach to potential DC Downsizers. Please help us do this by starting a monthly credit card pledge — it can be as low as $5 a month (which is just 17 cents per day). You can start your pledge using our secure online contribution form.

Please let us know if its okay to advertise your support here:

NEW MONTHLY PLEDGERS IN JUNE: Ginny Rober, Dwight E. Baker, David H. Abernathy, John Murphy, Jeremiah J Blanchard, TWO unlisted — IN MAY: Don Matesz, Silvy Berman, David Jones, Barbara Baxter, Nancy Kovar, Ryan Ackroyd, WM Michael O’Brien, John C Houghton, James Alan Speedie, THREE unlisted

Or, you could make a one-time donation. Please let us know on our secure contribution form if its okay to advertise your support here:

NEW ONE TIME DONORS IN JUNE: Patricia Barnum, Dwight E Baker, Rick Slusher, Dr. R.S. Gillinson, Edward J Krieger, Jan Berridge, EIGHT unlisted — IN MAY: Dorothy Davis, Arlene Lindstrand, Dee Clary, Joan Garro, Jennifer Tarling, Richard Linchitz, Steven Palmer, Bruce N. Liddel, Ernest P. Eusea, Chris Reulman, David Anthony, Christopher T Wagner, Thomas Sartwelle, Jr, EIGHT unlisted

If your comment is off-topic for this post, please email us at


Post a Comment

Notice: Undefined variable: user_ID in /var/www/ on line 89

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *

© 2008–2019